Case in point:
Does anything about the above panel suggest horror to you? I'm not saying this is bad art, just that it has no business being in a Tales from the Crypt title. Yeah, I get they're going in a new direction, but creative decisions like these suggest the creators were more interested in doing their own thing and only slapped a familiar title on it to sell it to an unsuspecting fan base. (I admit it worked on me, but isn't the idea to sell a series of comics, as opposed to just one?) This looks more like Sunday paper funnies and the other stories don't do much better of capturing the original run's spirit.
Below is probably the best panel from the entire thing:
There's something wrong when you have a lot less bite than your 1950s counterpart.